HomeAttorneysClient ReviewsArticlesIn The NewsPast ResultsContact

Jaroslawicz & Jaros Convinces NY’s Highest Court That Insurance Policy Limits Were Unreasonable

Written by
Abraham Jaros
|
Updated on Thursday, Sep 7, 2023

Jaroslawicz & Jaros Convinces NY's Highest Court that Insurance Policy Limits Were 'Unreasonable'

Jaroslawicz & Jaros has been litigating insurance cases for more than 30 years. As a result of their extensive experience in this field, the firm has been involved in many cases and appeals decided by higher courts. Many of these cases have helped shape and define New York’s insurance laws. It comes as no surprise then, that the firm’s New York City lawyers recently secured a favorable decision in the State’s highest court regarding unreasonable insurance provisions.

The firm’s case centered on two conflicting provisions common in New York “replacement cost" insurance policies-one stating that lawsuits to force an insurance company to pay the costs of replacement after a building is damaged by fire must be filed within two years after the fire; the other stating that a policyholder must replace the damaged property before filing the lawsuit. Although this policy language seems counterintuitive to many, insurance companies have used it for years as an excuse to avoid paying replacement costs to many owners of homes and commercial buildings, even though these policyholders paid premiums for this insurance. This particular case — Executive Plaza v. Peerless Insurance Company — involved a building that had experienced fire damage.

After an Executive Plaza building in Island Park was destroyed by fire in February 2007, Peerless Insurance refused to cover the replacement cost of new construction. Peerless claimed that because Executive Plaza failed to finish rebuilding after the fire within the two-year period stipulated on its $1 Million policy, the company lost the right to demand payment for the costs it had to spend to rebuild. Executive Plaza filed suit against Peerless Insurance in 2009, before the two years was up, but Peerless argued that the lawsuit was brought too soon because construction was still in progress-and the case was dismissed.

When the company finished construction and sued for replacement costs again, Peerless again refused to pay, this time asserting that the suit was brought too late because it was not filed within two years after the fire-and the case was again dismissed. Executive Plaza then retained Jaroslawicz & Jaros, who appealed, and the case came before the State Court of Appeals. Jaroslawicz & Jaros argued to protect the rights of policyholders who cannot reasonably replace damaged property within two years.

Attorneys David Jaroslawicz and David Tolchin at Jaroslawicz and Jaros-argued successfully on behalf of Executive Plaza, ultimately securing a decision from the Court that the time restrictions that insurance company attempted to hide behind were unreasonable in situations where repairs are time-consuming, such as in Executive Plaza’s situation. The decision paves the way for Executive Plaza to receive the coverage it paid for, and will likely play a role in protecting future policyholders from unfair New York insurance practices.

Get the advice and guidance you and your family need

You do not have to go through this alone.

At Jaroslawicz & Jaros, we have over 40 years of experience helping accident victims in New York recover compensation. The clients we represent benefit from the personal attention of our knowledgeable and experienced attorneys.

We Have Recovered Over $2 Billion for Our Clients.

The attorneys at Jaroslawicz & Jaros have obtained verdicts and settlements of over $1 Million for hundreds of our individual clients. Since all New York personal injury law firms generally charge the same legal fee why not hire an experienced law firm with a proven track record?

When you retain the New York City accident lawyers at Jaroslawicz & Jaros, you will always work directly with your lawyer, and not with a paralegal or secretary. We will always be available to you! Our hundreds of positive client reviews and testimonials speak for themselves.

Experience and a track record of results

Contact the attorneys at Jaroslawicz & Jaros for a free legal consultation regarding your rights and your legal options. If we agree to handle your case, we will work on a contingency fee basis so that you don’t have to worry about any upfront costs.

Contact us today for a free consultation

Picture of Abraham Jaros

You can reach partner Abraham Jaros directly, either call his cell 917-842-9544, or email him at ajaros@lawjaros.com. Or call Jaroslawicz & Jaros at 212 227 2780 in New York, or toll free 800-269-2780, or submit an online questionnaire.

Get the help you deserve

Contact us today and start your free consultation. You can also text or call Abraham Jaros directly at 917.842.9544 or email him at ajaros@lawjaros.com.

Send
Background picture of a courtroom

Helpful Videos

Awards & Recognitions

Badge Image
Badge Image
Badge Image
Badge Image
Badge Image
Badge Image
Badge Image
Badge Image
Badge Image
Badge Image
Badge Image
Badge Image
Badge Image
Badge Image
Badge Image
Badge Image