Switch to ADA Accessible Theme
Close Menu
New York City Injury Lawyer / Blog / Personal Injury / The Paper Trail Is Yours: Medical Records Rights in New York After a Bad Outcome

The Paper Trail Is Yours: Medical Records Rights in New York After a Bad Outcome

Med Record

When a surgery, a delivery, or a hospital stay does not go the way anyone expected, the chart often holds the first real answers. Our team of New York City personal injury lawyers sees how much a complete set of records can clarify, which is why patients are often surprised to learn that New York law gives them a statutory right of access.

What the Statute Provides

Public Health Law § 18 is the key provision. It says that, upon a patient’s written request, a health care provider must provide an opportunity within ten days to inspect the patient information in its possession. Copies must be furnished within a reasonable time on written request. The same section lets a provider charge a reasonable fee, but not more than seventy-five cents per page for paper copies, and it says a qualified person cannot be denied access solely because of inability to pay.

The term “qualified person” includes the patient, a parent of an infant, certain guardians, and in specific circumstances an attorney who holds a power of attorney that explicitly authorizes the request.

Records Patients Commonly Ask For

After a poor outcome, requests frequently include:

  • Admission and discharge summaries
  • Physician orders and progress notes
  • Nursing notes and medication administration records
  • Operative, anesthesia, and procedure reports
  • Laboratory results and imaging reports, along with the images themselves
  • Signed consent forms
  • Billing records showing what was charged

Providers that keep electronic records may handle requests differently than those that keep paper files, and special rules apply to certain categories, such as HIV-related and mental health information.

When a Request Is Denied

The law allows a provider to deny access in limited situations, such as when review could reasonably be expected to cause substantial and identifiable harm, or when the material consists of a practitioner’s personal notes and observations. If access is denied, the provider must explain the denial and tell the patient about the right to a no-cost review by a medical record access review committee. A further route to court exists within thirty days of the committee’s notification in certain circumstances.

Accuracy Counts Too

Section 18(8) also allows a qualified person to challenge the accuracy of factual information in the file and have a brief written statement added to it.

This post is a general overview of a statute and is not legal advice. How the law applies depends on each patient’s circumstances.

Questions About Your Records? Call Us

If you are trying to understand what happened during your care, Jaroslawicz & Jaros, PLLC is happy to talk. Reach out to us today and we will walk through your questions, one conversation at a time.

Source:

nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/PBH/18

×