Brooklyn Building Collapse Highlights Developer Liability for Damage Caused by Neighboring Construction

By Elizabeth Eilender:
News of the recent building collapse in Brooklyn is a devastating reminder of how quickly nearby construction and excavation can upend lives, shutter businesses, and destroy neighboring properties.
When a building collapse results in the tragic loss of life, destroyed homes, sudden vacate orders, and shattered livelihoods, victims and their families deserve justice. New York law provides powerful protections—and Jaroslawicz & Jaros PLLC helped set the precedent that enforces them.
In the landmark New York Court of Appeals decision Yenem Corp. v. 281 Broadway Holdings (18 N.Y.3d 481), our firm successfully represented a Manhattan pizzeria forced to close its doors after faulty deep excavation during construction next door caused its building to tilt nine inches.
We took the fight to New York’s highest court and won a unanimous ruling establishing critical protections for those harmed by neighboring excavation:
🔹 Absolute Liability: Under NYC’s excavation laws (formerly Admin. Code § 27-1031(b)(1)), developers and contractors who excavate more than 10 feet below curb level are strictly liable for resulting damage to adjoining structures.
🔹 Protecting Tenants & Neighbors: We proved that commercial tenants—not just building owners—can hold developers strictly liable when neighboring construction destroys their business.
🔹 No Excuses: Developers cannot escape liability by claiming they took “reasonable precautions” or by blaming the prior condition of the neighboring building. The financial risk falls squarely on the party doing the digging.
When reckless construction compromises your safety, displaces you from your home, or shuts down your business, you should never be left to bear the cost alone.
If you, your business, or your property has been impacted by the recent collapse in Brooklyn—or any nearby construction—contact Jaroslawicz & Jaros LLC for a free, confidential consultation. We have the experience and proven track record to hold negligent developers and contractors accountable
You can reach Elizabeth Eilender at:
Jaroslawicz & Jaros
225 Broadway, 24th floor
NYC, NY 10007
Office: 212-227-2780
Or email her at eeilender@lawjaros.com
You can also call Abraham Jaros on his cell at 917-842-9544
or, email him at ajaros@lawjaros.com
